Assessment of scientific and technical projects of priority directions of development based on the criterion of use value

The article deals with the problems of efficiency of evaluation and selection of scientific and technical projects of priority development directions of the national economy for their financing from the federal budget of the Russian Federation. The improvement of existing competitive procedures is proposed using the developed tool for the evaluation of the final result - the aggregate product of a scientific and technical project, considered as a set of all possible product outputs that have utility in various sectors of the economy, including as conversion solutions. For targeted use of the state’s investment resources in strategically effective areas, when selecting projects, it is proposed to link them to allocatively grouped sectors of the economy which consider the sectors of the strategic core as well as sectors of the I and II kind. The indicator of the aggregate product of the project is estimated by its use value as an additive form of convolution of the partial indicators of technical quality of all possible project outputs using the evaluation of their marketing support in possible sales markets. The article deals with the organizational and procedural schemes of proposed solutions for improving the evaluation of scientific and technical projects, as well as the economic and mathematical tools for ranking the priority directions for the development of the Russian economy for the financing of scientific and technical projects from the state budget. A polyciritorial evaluation of the final result of the project and use of the aggregate product as a resultant estimator of the use-value criterion makes it possible to objectify complex procedures for competitive selection of large-scale projects, increase their economic performance, as confirmed by the approbation studies on the example of the project for the creation and production of multifunctional on-board radar equipment.

contract system, scientific and technical project, competitive selection, the use value of the project, commercialization, state support for innovation, priority areas of development

1. Postanovlenie Pravitel’stva RF ot 2.08.2010 g. v red. ot 15.11.2017 № 588 «Ob utverzhdenii poryadka razrabotki, realizacii i ocenki ehffektivnosti gosudarstvennyh programm RF» [The decree of the RF Government dated August 2, 2010 as amended dated on 15.11.2017 № 588 «On approval of the procedure for the development, implementation and evaluation of the effectiveness of state programs of the Russian Federation»] (s izm. i dop., vstup. v silu s 01.01.2018). Sobranie zakonodatel›stva RF, 09.08.2010, №32, st. 4329.

2. Postanovlenie Pravitel›stva RF ot 12.10.2017 g. № 1242 «O razrabotke, realizacii i ob ocenke ehffektivnosti otdel›nyh gosudarstvennyh programm Rossijskoj Federacii». [The RF Government decree dated on 12.10.2017 № 1242 «On the design, implementation and evaluation of the effectiveness of individual state programs of the Russian Federation»]. Available at: http://www.pravo.gov.ru (accessed:18.02.2018).

3. Prikaz Ministerstva ehkonomicheskogo razvitiya RF ot 15.11.2017 g. № 607 «Ob utverzhdenii Metodicheskih rekomendacij po provedeniyu ranzhirovaniya proektov (programm) i vedomstvennyh celevyh programm s uchetom ocenki dostizheniya celej gosudarstvennyh programm Rossijskoj Federacii» [The order of the Ministry of economic development of the Russian Federation dated on 15.11.2017 № 607 «on approval of Methodological recommendations for the ranking of projects (programs) and departmental target programs, taking into account the assessment of the goals of the state programs of the Russian Federation. Available at: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_284067/

4. Prikaz Ministerstva ehkonomicheskogo razvitiya RF ot 09.06.2017 g. №285 «Ob utverzhdenii metodiki rascheta pokazatelej (indikatorov) gosudarstvennoj programmy Rossijskoj Federacii «EHkonomicheskoe razvitie i innovacionnaya ehkonomika». [The order of the Ministry of economic development of the Russian Federation of 09.06.2017 № 285 «on approval of the methodology for calculating indicators (indicators) of the state program of the Russian Federation «Economic development and innovation economy»]. Available at: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_221569/

5. Svodnyj otchet «Svedeniya o dostizhenii planovyh znachenij pokazatelej (indikatorov) po gosudarstvennym programmam za 2016 god» [Summary report 2016 «data on achievement of planned values of indicators (indicators) on the state programs for 2016»]. Oficial›nyj portal Gosprogramm RF. Available at: https://programs.gov.ru/opendata/ (accessed: 18.02.2018).

6. Novikov S.V. Nacional›naya ehkonomika kak krupnomasshtabnaya organizacionnaya social›no-ehkonomicheskaya sistema (KOSEHS) [National economy as a major organisational socio-economic system (COSES)] // Vestnik universiteta (Gosudarstvennyj universitet upravleniya) [University Bulletin (State University of Management)], 2014, I. 6, pp. 125-132.

7. Kossov V. V., Livshits V. N., Shahnazarov A. G. Metodicheskie rekomendacii po ocenke ehffektivnosti investicionnyh proektov i ih otboru dlya finansirovaniya. [Methodological recommendations for evaluating the effectiveness of investment projects and their selection for financing]. Vtoraya redakciya. Oficial’noe izdanie. M.: Ehkonomika, 2000. 421 p.

8. Zakharova L. F., Novikov S. V. Upravlenie konkursnym otborom vysokotekhnologichnyh nauchno – tekhnicheskih proektov. [Management of competitive selection of high-tech scientific and technical projects]. M.: Izd-vo MAI, 2016. 160 p.

9. Postalyuk M. P., Andrianov D. S., Postalyuk T. M. Upravlenie innovatizaciej institucional›noj sistemy kak faktor ustojchivogo razvitiya rossijskoj ehkonomiki. [Management innovatsia institutional system as a factor of sustainable development of the Russian economy]. Problemy ehkonomiki. 2017, I. 3 (63), pp. 10-14.

10. Formirovanie hozyajstvennogo mekhanizma transformacii innovacionnogo razvitiya social›no – ehkonomicheskih sistem [Formation of economic mechanism of transformation of innovative development of social and economic systems]. Monografiya. Pod obshch. red. M. N. Dudina – M.: Izdatel’stvo «Elit», 2015. 400 p